LOCATION: Anegada, British Virgin Islands
CUISINE: Seafood
PRICE POINT: $$$ (out of $$$$)
OVERALL RATING: 9/10
DESCRIPTION:
Anegada is easily one of the most beautiful and serene islands in the BVI. Sailing over from Virgin Gorda, we secured our catamaran to a mooring buoy and took our dinghy up to the Lobster Trap dock lined with twinkle lights. Looking over the side of the dock we saw traps with fresh lobster floating in the ocean.
Looking up at millions of stars, The Lobster Trap provides a relaxing ambiance with fantastic views. The one catch here is that it is important to make your reservation and place your dinner order by 4PM the same day to secure your lobster dish for the evening. After ordering drinks, a family-size salad was brought to the table with homemade bread and dressing and condiments (while options are limited to caesar or thousand island) were set out on the table picnic style. The service was surprisingly quick compared to the "island time" most BVI restaurants keep, and the staff was very friendly.
Five finished lobsters later, we all agreed that this lobster was impeccable - extremely tender and felt as if it melted in your mouth. While most people prefer Maine lobster, this is far and away the best lobster we've had in the Caribbean. Our lobster dishes were served with a side of melted butter and baked potato, and we overheard the waitress explain that they do not boil their lobsters – simply grill and season them. Dessert options included key lime pie and carrot cake, both of which were satisfying endings to a pleasant evening on the water.
Though a bit pricier, the food is well worth the cost. Check out more reviews and pictures here:
Anegada is the furthest of the British Virgin Islands that we ventured to. Though the waters can be a bit choppy on the ride over, it is definitely worth the trip. The waters are exquisite green and blue colors and the North end of the island provides great snorkeling around reefs for those who seek adventure. We spent time snorkeling at Loblolly Bay but harsh Christmas winds made it difficult to swim against the current. Hoping to explore Cow Wreck Beach next time (on the West end of the island and the site of an old shipwreck). Since there are no moorings on the north side, we recommend docking near the town and taking scooters around the island (you can rent them by the hour or day) to explore the beautiful beaches and landscape.
